Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Chris Overholser's avatar

Great piece, Charlie

Expand full comment
Greg Seamon's avatar

I believe that coaches have long asked QB's to review the game plan and highlight their favorite plays. I do not believe that is anything new. I have noticed this trend of involving star QB's in organizational decision making and, frankly, I don't think it is a good idea. The emboldened QB who makes comments for a teammate in the press is also not advocating for another teammate in so doing. A locker room that knows the QB has the ear of management will watch what he says closely; some will try to negotiate with management through him. If a star QB advocates for his offensive buddies and the defensive players see one of their own stars lose out it can cause a problem. If he shares an agent with another contract-seeking player there is real risk of a conflict of interest. Coaches and GM's have always sought the council of trusted veteran players regarding how they view certain teammates or potential free agent signees, but that has been done privately and not as a normal course of business. Being the star QB is hard enough without carrying the weight of roster building as well. As many coaches and GM's realize each year, being part of the roster building group is great when you are winning, but if things go badly as a team and/or the QB's performance suffers, a locker room can be lost.

Expand full comment

No posts